Disadvantages of Job Descriptions

By Nicole Vulcan
23655713
Hemera Technologies/PhotoObjects.net/Getty Images

When you're hiring to fill a new position, the first thing you may do is create a job description to give the new hire an idea of your expectations. While this is pretty standard and may seem without controversy, the fact is that creating a job description can lead to misconceptions and excess work for employees and employers. Before you choose to create formal job descriptions, review the potential disadvantages.

Commiting To It

Decide whether you have time to create a well-written and detailed job description. Determining the duties of a job may require researching the operations of an entire department and getting input from managers. Rounds of reviews may follow before a final description is written. In a company that lacks human resource professionals to create job descriptions, an employee must take time away from their regular duties to do so.

Pigeonholing

If you've ever heard the phrase "it's not my job" thrown around your workplace, then you may understand another potential issue with detailed job descriptions. Some employees may consider a job description to be the definitive documentation of what they are expected to do – and not do – in the position. As a result, they may be unwilling to take on extra tasks or go the extra mile because it's not in their job description. At the same time, a formal job description may limit an employer's view of an employee's capabilities, resulting in missed opportunities for promotions of and contributions from certain employees.

Keeping It Balanced

Potential job candidates can be negatively affected by a poorly-written or overly-written job descriptions as well. A job description with an exhaustive list of duties and responsibilities may overwhelm even the most qualified candidates, and a poorly-written one can confuse the candidate or impart a negative impression about the company. As a result, some may feel too intimidated to apply for the job or not apply at all.

Adding Touch Ups

Overseeing job descriptions take time and effort. When a key feature of a job changes, the job description must be updated. This requires more effort by managers to revise job descriptions as needed. This may make a case for a less-detailed job description. A vague description requires more initiative on the part of the employee to interpret its meaning – and possibly less work on the part of the manager who has to update it.

About the Author

Nicole Vulcan has been a journalist since 1997, covering parenting and fitness for The Oregonian, careers for CareerAddict, and travel, gardening and fitness for Black Hills Woman and other publications. Vulcan holds a Bachelor of Arts in English and journalism from the University of Minnesota. She's also a lifelong athlete and is pursuing certification as a personal trainer.